Modern cases

Declared Dead but Still Alive: What Real Cases Teach Us

Our great-grandparents feared the cemetery. We fear the body bag and the cold room. Here are the best-known modern cases of people wrongly declared dead, sorted by how well they are documented, and what they have in common.

Two things first. These cases are exceedingly rare: there is no reliable statistic on how often they occur, but the worldwide coverage each one gets is itself a sign of rarity. And not all stories are equal. Below we separate documented cases (official reports or investigations), cases reported by the press without an accessible public document, and unverified stories.

Iowa, January 2023: the body bag that breathed (documented)

On January 3, 2023, a 66-year-old woman with dementia, receiving hospice care at the Glen Oaks Alzheimer’s Special Care Center in Urbandale, Iowa, was declared dead by staff. According to the investigation report of the Iowa Department of Inspections and Appeals, as reported by the Associated Press, ABC News, NBC and the Washington Post, a nurse practitioner examined her for about five minutes before declaring death.

She was placed in a zipped body bag and taken to a funeral home in Ankeny. When staff opened the bag, they saw her chest rising and her gasping for air. She was taken to hospital, returned to hospice care, and died on January 5, 2023, with her family, according to the state report. Iowa fined the facility $10,000.

The case is a textbook example. Her death was expected, which may have shaped the examination. Her dementia limited her ability to react. And the error was caught only because funeral home staff opened the bag instead of placing the body straight into cold storage.

Ecuador, June 2023: knocking on the coffin (documented)

On June 9, 2023, in Babahoyo, Ecuador, a 76-year-old woman, Bella Montoya, was declared dead in hospital after a possible stroke and cardiorespiratory arrest, according to Ecuador’s Ministry of Health as quoted by the Associated Press. During the wake a few hours later, relatives heard knocking on the coffin, opened it, and found her breathing. She was taken back to intensive care. The ministry announced an investigation and a technical committee to review how the hospital issues death certificates. Later press reports said she died about a week afterward; that has not been confirmed by an official source.

Mississippi, February 2014 (reported)

In Lexington, Mississippi, a 78-year-old man, Walter Williams, was declared dead at home by the county coroner, according to the U.S. media that covered the case. At the funeral home, staff noticed him moving his legs inside the body bag. He was hospitalized and died about two weeks later, according to the same reports. The coroner reportedly suggested that a pacemaker might have restarted his heart; that explanation was not medically confirmed in the sources available.

Poland, January 2014 (reported)

In Ostrów Lubelski, a 91-year-old woman, Janina Kolkiewicz, was declared dead at home by a physician, according to the Polish and then the international press. About eleven hours later, in a funeral home’s cold room, staff noticed her moving. She went home. Widely reported, but no official Polish document could be consulted.

How to read a viral “resurrection” story

The internet is full of people who supposedly woke up in a morgue or coffin. Some stories come from reputable media relying only on families or funeral staff; others are hoaxes. Three questions help:

  1. Is there a specific name, date and place?
  2. Has an authority (hospital, ministry, police, court) confirmed the facts?
  3. Is it covered by several independent outlets, or merely copied?

Why these mistakes happen

Looking at the documented cases, the error is almost never due to some mysterious condition. It comes from a clinical state that makes signs of life faint, combined with an examination too limited to detect them.

Conditions that mimic death

  • Hypothermia. Cold slows the heart and breathing dramatically. Emergency medicine’s saying: “Nobody is dead until they’re warm and dead.” In 1999, the Swedish doctor Anna Bågenholm was trapped under ice in Norway for about eighty minutes and found in cardiac arrest with a core temperature of 13.7 °C (56.7 °F). Rewarmed with extracorporeal circulation in Tromsø, she survived; her case was published in The Lancet in 2000.
  • Poisoning. Barbiturates, sedatives, opioids, very large amounts of alcohol and some poisons can cause deep coma with very slow breathing. That is why brain death protocols require poisoning to be ruled out.
  • Severe metabolic disorders, such as profound hypoglycemia or organ failure.
  • The end of life itself: irregular breathing with long pauses and a very weak pulse can be mistaken for death.
  • Autoresuscitation: the heart can restart after CPR stops, the Lazarus phenomenon.

Human and organizational factors

  • Expectation: when everyone expects a death, the examiner may confirm rather than verify.
  • Haste: a few seconds, or minutes without prolonged listening, can miss faint signs.
  • Conditions: darkness, no stethoscope or monitor, a tired or inexperienced examiner.
  • Qualifications: depending on the place, physicians, nurses, or elected coroners without medical training may pronounce death.
  • No observation afterward: a closed bag and cold storage remove any chance of later detection.

The lesson

Modern cases of “waking up” are rare, but real, and they follow a simple logic: the apparent absence of signs of life is not proof of death. Proof rests on a methodical examination of sufficient length that takes the context into account. We describe that examination in how doctors confirm death. For families, the book’s final chapter offers a practical guide: questions to ask, and what to do in case of doubt.

Sources

  1. Iowa Department of Inspections and Appeals, investigation report on the Glen Oaks Alzheimer’s Special Care Center (2023), as reported by the Associated Press, ABC News, NBC and the Washington Post, February 2023.
  2. Associated Press, “Woman declared dead knocks on coffin during her own wake in Ecuador,” June 2023.
  3. Press coverage of the Walter Williams case (Mississippi), February 2014 (BBC, ABC News).
  4. Press coverage of the Janina Kolkiewicz case (Poland), January 2014 (Polish media, BBC, The Guardian).
  5. Gilbert M. et al., “Resuscitation from accidental hypothermia of 13.7 °C with circulatory arrest,” The Lancet, 2000; 355: 375–376.
  6. Hornby K., Hornby L., Shemie S. D., “A systematic review of autoresuscitation after cardiac arrest,” Critical Care Medicine, 2010; 38(5): 1246–1253.