The Lazarus Phenomenon: When the Heart Restarts After CPR Stops
Sometimes, after resuscitation has been stopped as unsuccessful, the heart starts again on its own. Doctors call it the Lazarus phenomenon. It is rare, it is real, and it has shaped how death is declared.
This article explains published medical research for a general audience. It is not medical advice.
A biblical name for a medical observation
The Lazarus phenomenon, also called autoresuscitation, is the spontaneous return of circulation in a patient after cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR) has been stopped. The name refers to the Gospel of John, in which Jesus raises Lazarus four days after his death. The medical reality is far more modest: a heart that starts beating again minutes after the resuscitation team has given up.
The phenomenon was described in the medical literature from the 1980s onward and acquired its name in the early 1990s. Each published case is usually a single report, which makes it hard to know how often it happens. Several cases have probably gone unnoticed, simply because nobody was watching the patient after resuscitation ended.
What the 2010 systematic review found
In 2010, Katharine Hornby, Laura Hornby and Sam Shemie published a systematic review of autoresuscitation in Critical Care Medicine. Gathering the cases published in the medical literature, they identified around thirty, according to the review. Their key finding concerned timing: where it was reported, the return of circulation occurred in the great majority of cases within ten minutes of stopping CPR. Some patients survived, a few with good neurological recovery.
Ten minutes is a short window. But it is long enough to matter if a death is declared the moment the team steps back from the bed and the body is moved shortly afterward.
Why would a heart restart on its own?
The mechanisms are still debated. Two hypotheses come up most often:
- Pulmonary hyperinflation. During resuscitation, air blown into the lungs too quickly can build up pressure in the chest, which impedes the return of blood to the heart. When ventilation stops, pressure falls, blood flows back, and the heart may restart.
- Delayed drug effects. Medications given during resuscitation, such as epinephrine (adrenaline), may take effect late, once circulation conditions change.
Neither explanation is proven for every case. What matters for practice is the observation itself.
The 2021 NEJM study: what happens after the heart stops
A different setting produced the best data so far. In 2021, the New England Journal of Medicine published a study led by the Canadian pediatric intensivist Sonny Dhanani. The team prospectively followed 631 adult patients who died after a planned withdrawal of life-sustaining treatment in 20 intensive care units in three countries. These were not CPR cases: the heart stopped after treatment was withdrawn, under continuous monitoring.
Their results:
- in 5 patients (1%), clinicians at the bedside saw cardiac or respiratory activity resume after a period without a pulse;
- analysis of the ECG and arterial pressure recordings of 480 patients found a transient resumption of cardiac activity after a pulseless period in 67 of them (14%);
- the longest interval between loss of pulse and resumption was 4 minutes 20 seconds;
- no patient regained lasting circulation or consciousness.
Two lessons follow. The heart does not always stop all at once: it can briefly restart, sometimes more than once, in the minutes after arrest. And these resumptions are transient and happen within a short window.
How this shaped the rules
The five-minute rule in organ donation
In organ donation after circulatory death, organs are retrieved after the heart has stopped, typically when the medical team and the family have decided to withdraw treatment that has become futile. The crucial question is how long to wait before death is final. Many countries and protocols require five minutes without circulation, verified by invasive monitoring. The Dhanani study, whose longest resumption was 4 minutes 20 seconds, was widely seen as supporting that interval. National rules vary and should be checked in the texts in force.
Observation after unsuccessful CPR
After resuscitation is stopped, many teams recommend continuing to observe the patient for at least ten minutes, with monitoring if possible, before declaring death. That figure follows directly from the timing seen in the published Lazarus cases. Exact recommendations vary between countries and professional societies.
What it means, and what it doesn’t
The Lazarus phenomenon is sometimes cited online as proof that “doctors can’t really tell when someone is dead.” That is the wrong conclusion. The phenomenon happens in a very specific situation (just after resuscitation), within a short and known window. It is precisely because clinicians studied it that observation periods now exist. A death confirmed after an adequate observation period, with a careful check of central pulse and breathing, is not the same thing as a death declared the second CPR stops.
It also connects with older fears. In the eighteenth century, Winslow and Bruhier argued that only decomposition proved death. Modern medicine answers that a methodical examination is enough, provided it lasts long enough and takes the context into account: recent resuscitation, cold, drugs. The Lazarus phenomenon is one of the reasons that “long enough” has a number attached to it.
Hypothermia: a related warning
A different situation calls for even more caution. In deep hypothermia, the heart and breathing can slow to the point of being undetectable. Emergency medicine’s rule, “nobody is dead until they’re warm and dead,” means death is not declared before rewarming has been attempted, unless injuries are clearly incompatible with life. The 1999 case of Anna Bågenholm, who survived a core temperature of 13.7 °C, is the best-known illustration, described in our article on real cases.
For the full list of what a sound death pronouncement includes, see signs of death: how doctors confirm it.
Sources
- Hornby K., Hornby L., Shemie S. D., “A systematic review of autoresuscitation after cardiac arrest,” Critical Care Medicine, 2010; 38(5): 1246–1253.
- Dhanani S. et al., “Resumption of Cardiac Activity after Withdrawal of Life-Sustaining Measures,” New England Journal of Medicine, 2021; 384: 345–352, doi:10.1056/NEJMoa2022713.
- Gilbert M. et al., “Resuscitation from accidental hypothermia of 13.7 °C with circulatory arrest,” The Lancet, 2000; 355: 375–376.
- European Resuscitation Council, guidelines on cardiac arrest in special circumstances (hypothermia).
- Gospel of John, chapter 11 (origin of the name).